Book Series List Your guide to reading book series in the correct order. Browse thousands of authors and series.
Legal As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
© 2026 Book Series List. All rights reserved.
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Series by Elizabeth Adams - Reading Order | Book Series List
Home Elizabeth Adams Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Series by Elizabeth Adams
The Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries series by Elizabeth Adams consists of 27 books, published between 2015 and 2025. The series begins with Peace Like a River (By: Olivia Newport).
1 Peace Like a River (By: Olivia Newport) (2015)
2
Blessing in Disguise (By: Nancy Mehl) (2015)
3 Where Hope Dwells (By: Elizabeth Ludwig) (2015)
4 The Buggy Before the Horse (By: Tricia Goyer) (2015)
5 A Season of Secrets (2015)
6 O Little Town of Sugarcreek (By: Amy Lee Lillard) (2015)
7 Off the Beaten Path (By: Annalisa Daughety) (2015)
8 Simply Vanished (By: Nancy Mehl) (2016)
9 Stranger Things Have Happened (By: Amy Lillard) (2016)
10 No Time for Trouble (By: Olivia Newport) (2016)
11 A Stitch in Time (By: Elizabeth Ludwig) (2016)
12 Shoo, FLY, Shoo (By: Amy Lillard) (2016)
13 Home Sweet Sugarcreek (By: Elizabeth Ludwig) (2016)
14 When There's a Will (2016)
16 All Abuzz at the Honey Bee (By: Nancy Mehl) (2016)
17 Mason Jar Mayhem (By: Cara C. Putman) (2016)
18 Earthly Treasures (By: Annalisa Daughety) (2016)
19 A Tempting Taste Of Mystery (By: Elizabeth Ludwig) (2017)
20 Digging Up Doubts (By: Olivia Newport) (2017)
21 A Play On Words (By: Emily Thomas) (2017)
22 In the Fullness of Time (2017)
23 Horse Sense and Sensibility (By: Nancy Mehl) (2017)
24 Secrets Plain and Simple (By: Elizabeth Ludwig) (2018)
25 When Angels Whisper (By: Nancy Mehl) (2022)
26 Hark! The Herald Angel Falls (By: Tricia Goyer) (2024)
27 O Little Town of Sugarcreek (By: Amy Lillard) (2025)